Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE
Posted by Mass Lyme on 10/31/08
CFS is not a real illness, it's manufactured by the government and insurance companies to create a patient catagory. What makes you sick didn't make me sick, we are all individuals with different illnesses. Many of these so-called CFS patients have Lyme like me. I know someone who brain and nervous system was damaged from tear gas, I know others with hypothylamic hormonal deficiencies,mould, and many, many, many, with Lyme. The worst things a doctor can do is hang the CFS diagnosis around your neck. I have seen too much, these CFS doctors like Klimas, Bell, Levine have allowed so many patients untreated for Lyme. May the "Lymelight" shine shame on them.Damn them. On 10/21/08, ErikMoldWarrior wrote: > On 10/21/08, Deborah wrote: >> Many doctors get tunnel vision when they are working on particular illnesses that mainstream medicine fails to or >> inadequately addresses; it becomes the diagnosis du jour. >> >> Not an excuse, just an explanation. I have never met the doctor nor know anything about her. >> >> On another note, chronic fatigue is thought to be caused by Epstein-Barr, chemical sensitivities and/or exposures, >> misdiagnoses and thus unnecessary or improper treatment ( read antibiotics, steroids, etc ), or a varying combination of >> all three. >> > > > If you want to hear the most amazing story, read Osler's Web by Hillary Johnson. > The key word here is "Syndrome", to differentiate the 1988 Holmes "CFS definition" from mere prolonged fatigue. > In the early 1980's outbreaks of inexplicable "chronic mononucleosis" caused the CDC to postulate a vague descripion that > was called "Chronic Epstein Barr Virus Syndrome (CEBV Syndrome)" > Dr Cheney and Dr Peterson of Incline Village tried to "impress" this concept upon an outbreak of illness that occurrred > there in 1985, and found that this was completely wrong. > The immune parameters didn't match. > Dr Peterson called the CDC for clarification, and the epidemiologists Jon Kaplan and Gary Holmes came out to conduct a > quick investigation - and reassure these "confused doctors" that all they were looking at was "CEBV Syndrome". > > But Dr Cheney's evidence was so undeniable that the CDC was forced to abandon their "Chronic Mono" concept and rename the > illness - which wound up being "Chronic Fatigue Syndrome". > The patients used as prototypes had deformed B cells, low red cell mass, abnormally low erythrocyte sedimentation rates - > ween ONLY in less than half a dozen other illnesses, depleted RNase-L (an antiviral enzyme), extremely abnormal levels of > platelet debris, high Interleukin 2, and a whole slew of other weirdnesses that are too numerous to list here. > > The bottom line is that EBV was only reactivated, and was not inherent nor necessary to the syndrome. > > It is quite ironic that the creation of CFS was forced by the incontrovertible evidence that EBV was a side issue, and yet, > twenty years after the fact, the CDC has never bothered to make this point clear to the medical community. > -ErikMW > Incline Village CFS survivor
Posts on this thread, including this one
- shoemaker, 10/08/03, by sacliff@msn.com.
- Re: shoemaker, 10/09/03, by ff.
- Re: shoemaker, 10/11/03, by sherrie.
- Re: shoemaker, 10/12/03, by ff.
- Re: sherri eseeking info, 10/12/03, by ff.
- Re: sherri eseeking info, 10/15/03, by sherrie.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 12/01/03, by Terry Elias.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/29/04, by Nancy Bramson.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 2/10/04, by Teresa Greene.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 2/13/04, by Karen Parisis.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/29/04, by IanChristopher.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/29/04, by IanChristopher.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 4/02/04, by Gloria Horsley.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 4/02/04, by SD Teacher.
- Re: sherri eseeking info, 4/12/04, by sherrie.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/03/05, by john biles.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/04/05, by Greg Weatherman.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/06/05, by Kay Bowers.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/07/05, by curious.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/25/05, by Eric.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/25/05, by Greg Weatherman.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/29/05, by Eric.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/29/05, by Eric.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/29/05, by Eric.
- Re: ERIC, 1/30/05, by ff.
- Re: ERIC, 1/30/05, by ff.
- Re: shoemaker, 1/31/05, by Jyl Burgener.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 2/01/05, by Eric.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 2/02/05, by ff.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 2/24/05, by suzanne mccavanagh.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 2/24/05, by suzanne mccavanagh.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/29/05, by Janice.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker - wow, i'm stunned, 3/30/05, by mary.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker - wow, i'm stunned, 3/30/05, by Greg Weatherman.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker - wow, i'm stunned, 3/30/05, by mary.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/30/05, by v.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 5/12/05, by Andrea.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 5/22/05, by ZXR90.
- Re: shoemaker, 8/01/05, by Jim.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 8/05/05, by Linda Lee Johnson.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 8/05/05, by Linda Lee Johnson.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 9/14/05, by vivian.
- Re: shoemaker, 9/14/05, by vivian.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 10/08/05, by ANN.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 10/08/05, by ANN.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 10/10/05, by terry.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 11/27/05, by Marty Clarke.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 12/20/05, by Kurt D. Winterkorn.
- Re: Dr. Wintercorn, 12/21/05, by ff.
- Re: Dr. Shoemaker/Mr. Winterkorn, 12/21/05, by Tammy.
- Re: Dr. Wintercorn, 12/21/05, by v.
- Re: Re:Tammy/Mrs. Winterkorn, 12/23/05, by ff.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 12/23/05, by TMV.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 12/23/05, by A Griffith.
- Re: Re:Tammy/Mrs. Winterkorn, 12/23/05, by Greg Weatherman.
- Re: FF, 1/11/06, by DD.
- Re: FF, 2/28/06, by Sue.
- Re: FF, 2/28/06, by Sue.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/21/06, by Pat Romanosky.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 5/06/06, by Holly.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 7/02/06, by ed cohen.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 7/02/06, by ed cohen.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 9/11/06, by ANDREE Tanner.
- Re: shoemaker, 11/27/06, by Craig.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 11/29/06, by NOT AMUSED.
- Re: shoemaker, 12/16/06, by Kay.
- Re: shoemaker, 12/29/06, by AmerAcadMed1.
- Re: shoemaker, 3/13/07, by Claire.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/13/07, by Claire.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 3/14/07, by Fanua SP. (SCUPS-Student).
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 4/13/07, by Cindy Fulghum.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker--BAD EXPERIENCE WITH DR. SHOEMAKER, 5/01/07, by Virginia.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker--BAD EXPERIENCE WITH DR. SHOEMAKER, 5/01/07, by Virginia.
- Re: shoemaker, a real cruel stinker, 5/01/07, by Virginia.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 5/10/07, by David MacRae.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 6/13/07, by Tracy Hans.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 6/14/07, by ff.
- Re: shoemaker, a real cruel stinker -- WRONG!!, 8/01/07, by dlpgppmi.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 8/05/07, by john LaRocque.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 8/05/07, by john LaRocque.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker--I'm not!!!!!, 9/09/07, by DC chick.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 9/09/07, by dc chick.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 9/09/07, by DC CHICK.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 9/09/07, by dc chick.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 9/09/07, by ff.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 9/16/07, by DC.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 9/16/07, by ff.
- Re: shoemaker, a real cruel stinker -- WRONG!!, 10/02/07, by Cory .
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 10/20/07, by sick and tired.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 10/21/07, by ff.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 10/21/07, by Audrey Schueck.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 10/21/07, by Audrey WS.
- Re: Dr. Shoemaker: One of a Kind, 10/21/07, by Erik Johnson.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 10/23/07, by ff.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker, Dr.Norton Fishman, A Better Choice, 11/04/07, by Rob.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker, Dr.Norton Fishman, A Better Choice, 11/06/07, by ff.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker, Dr.Norton Fishman, A Better Choice, 12/01/07, by Nikki.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker, Dr.Norton Fishman, A Better Choice, 12/01/07, by Nikki.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 12/23/07, by Tracy.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 12/27/07, by Melody.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 12/27/07, by melody.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 12/28/07, by ff.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 12/28/07, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 12/28/07, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Shoemaker/defending/clarity, 1/05/08, by Tracy.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 1/05/08, by ff.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/09/08, by Tracy.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/09/08, by ff.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/18/08, by Tracy.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/19/08, by ff.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/19/08, by Ticked off.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/19/08, by Ticked Off.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/19/08, by Ticked Off.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/20/08, by ff.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/20/08, by ff.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 1/20/08, by ff.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/20/08, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/22/08, by Tracy.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/22/08, by ff.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/22/08, by ff.
- Re: To FF/ Dr. Shoemaker, 1/27/08, by Tracy.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 2/22/08, by Deborah.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 2/22/08, by ff.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 3/03/08, by Deborah.
- Re: Shoemaker, better CFS doctor than Dr. James Baranuik GU, 3/08/08, by JL.
- Re: Shoemaker, better CFS doctor than Dr. James Baranuik GU, 4/06/08, by Me2, another lymie.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 4/06/08, by me2.
- Re: Dr. James Baraniuk, 5/03/08, by Another CFS/CBT victim.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 5/21/08, by Katie.
- Re: Dr. James Baraniuk, 5/21/08, by Katie.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 5/25/08, by Tracy.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 6/09/08, by Jill.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 6/09/08, by Jill.
- Re: June 23rd, 6/17/08, by Tracy.
- Re: June 23rd, 6/27/08, by mgfs.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 6/30/08, by Paul B. Ross.
- Re: June 23rd, 7/08/08, by Robert Christ.
- Re: June 23rd, 7/13/08, by S.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 7/16/08, by Bruce.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 7/21/08, by Seattle.
- Re: Shoemaker, better CFS doctor than Dr. James Baranuik GU, 7/21/08, by Seattle.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 7/28/08, by Former Klimas Patient.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 8/15/08, by Bad Experience.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 8/15/08, by Bad Experience.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 8/15/08, by BE.
- Re: June 23rd, 8/16/08, by Robert Christ.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 9/11/08, by Mary Ann.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with NO caveat, 9/11/08, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 9/14/08, by Joanie.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 9/14/08, by Joani.
- Re: Defending Shoemaker with caveat, 9/14/08, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 9/21/08, by EnisP.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/11/08, by Surfer Chick.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/11/08, by Surfer Chick, Also........
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/12/08, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/19/08, by Maria.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/21/08, by Deborah.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/21/08, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Nancy Klimas, MD--MISDIAGNOSIS, 10/31/08, by Mass Lyme.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, 10/31/08, by Mass Lyme.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 10/31/08, by Mass Lyme.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas doesn't test for Lyme Disease, 10/31/08, by Mass Lyme.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/01/08, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Nancy Klimas, MD--MISDIAGNOSIS, 11/21/08, by Pat.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/21/08, by Pat.
- Re: Shoemaker, better CFS doctor than Dr. James Baranuik GU, 11/21/08, by Pat.
- Re: Shoemaker, better CFS doctor than Dr. James Baranuik GU, 11/26/08, by johncodie.
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 1/17/09, by Cat Budak.
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 1/18/09, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 1/19/09, by Mike B..
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 1/19/09, by ErikMoldWarrior.
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 1/19/09, by Mike B..
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 3/26/09, by TROB.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 5/27/09, by Diana.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 6/28/09, by Helen Rinde.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 7/01/09, by Pat Sullivan.
- Re: Dr. Leila Zachrison, 7/01/09, by Colleen.
- Re: Dr. Leila Zackrison, 7/01/09, by Colleen.
- Re: Dr. Leila Zackrison, 7/09/09, by SD.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 7/09/09, by S.
- Re: Shoemaker & Cholestryramine Therapy for Mold Illness, 7/09/09, by SD.
- Re: Re:CHINESE DRYWALL, 7/12/09, by HARVARD 708.
- Re: Re:CHINESE DRYWALL, 7/13/09, by Rem Dude.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 7/21/09, by kat shaw.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 7/21/09, by kat shaw.
- Re: Shoemaker, better than CFS experts at Georgetown Uni, 7/22/09, by CFSer.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/02/09, by Bric.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/10/09, by Patient.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/10/09, by bric.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/11/09, by Patient.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/11/09, by bric.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/28/09, by recovering mold pt..
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/28/09, by recovering mold pt..
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 8/29/09, by bric.
- Re: MCS factors, 8/29/09, by recovering mold pt..
- Re: MCS factors, 8/30/09, by bric.
- Re: MCS factors, 9/04/09, by recovering mold pt..
- Re: MCS factors, 9/08/09, by recovering mold pt..
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 9/11/09, by Pat Lassiter.
- Re: Shoemaker, 9/13/09, by Mold-Ill Patient.
- Re: William Rea MD, 9/28/09, by Lisa Nagy MD.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 10/09/09, by Pat Romanosky.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Shoemaker, 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 11/06/09, by Peterson.
- Re: Dr. Nancy Klimas, A BAD EXPERIENCE , 11/06/09, by Lee Robin.
- Re: Dr. Klimas is A Fantastic CFS / XMRV Physician, 11/06/09, by Lee Robin.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 11/08/09, by Feagles.
- Re: Defending Dr. Shoemaker, 11/17/09, by maggie k.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/09/10, by LRHH.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/09/10, by LRHH.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker, 1/09/10, by LRHH.
- Re: Dr. Ritchie Shoemaker--BAD EXPERIENCE WITH DR. SHOEMAKER, 1/18/10, by Confused.
- Re: Dr. Richie Shoemaker , 3/14/10, by Dottie.
|